Imagination and the Brain

Metaphors Light Up The BrainThere is a report of an interesting study on Psych Central about how metaphors are processed in the brain. The main point is that when someone hears a metaphor with a textural quality,  the parietal operculum,  the region of the brain that senses texture through touch, is activated . 

This is an interesting study for depth psychology for, as Jung states, "An archetypal content expresses itself, first and foremost, in metaphors." 

This study, I believe, provides support for Jung's notion that symbols (metaphors of an archetypal nature) are "the best possible expression for something that cannot be expressed  otherwise than by a more or less close analogy." In other words, it is not just through rational processes that something is understood. The non-rational functions of sensing and intuition are necessary to grasp symbolic and metaphoric images. 

This is represented in the brain by the activation of the part of the brain that senses touch. Metaphors, then, are not primarily processed by the language centers of the brain. Therefore, we cannot just understand a symbol intellectually. We have to get it on a "gut level," too.  When an archetypal content is expressed in a dream or a myth we impoverish our understanding by trying to grasp it only with our reason, approaching it only on the semantic level. Our whole body is addressed and needs to be engaged  by the symbolic material.

Of course, being brain researchers, the authors of the study conceptualize what is happening in terms of their preferred metaphor: the brain. Here is their formulation for what they are seeing:
"What could be happening is that the brain is conducting an internal simulation as a way to understand the metaphor, and that’s why the regions associated with touch get involved. This also demonstrates how complex processes involving symbols, such as appreciating a painting or understanding a metaphor, do not depend just on evolutionarily new parts of the brain, but also on adaptations of older parts of the brain.”
I assume when they say "the brain is conducting an internal simulation," they mean that the imagination has been activated, but then I prefer to think and speak and imagine in terms of the soul and the imagination. Not that I think the brain is not involved. It clearly is. However, there is the whole matter of correlation vs. causation and, as far as I can tell, the only reason to decide in favor of the idea that the brain produces psychic phenomena or, for that matter, consciousness, is a preference for a rigid materialist philosophy.

I prefer Joseph Campbell's formulation which allows for the engagement of what might be called the body-psyche, of which the brain is but one part:
"Myths and dreams are motivated from a single psychophysiological source--namely, the human imagination moved by the conflicting urgencies of the organs (including the brain) of the human body, of which the anatomy has remained  pretty much the same since c. 40, 000 BC."
Posted in C.G. Jung, Depth Psychology, Soul.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *